Disability Rights Watch

Tag: eugenics

  • Week 13 Updates

    1. White House asks Congress to Eliminate Head Start Funding. The current budget draft eliminates funding for Head Start, which provides early education, meals, and health screenings for pre-k kids. The elimination of Head Start was a stated goal of Project 2025.

      Head Start outcomes are extremely successful, showing benefits for children in early literacy, social-emotional skills, health and dental improvements, early intervention for disabilities, and a >90% decrease in the need for family separation and foster care.

      Many preschools–which include both public and private programs–who receive the funding were already struggling due to earlier federal freezes and staffing cuts.
    2. US Citizen arrested on ICE hold, while White House flouts SCOTUS rulings and wants expansion of camps for “homegrowns.” Trump met with the President of El Salvador, and the two congratulated themselves on the imprisonment of asylum seekers and legal US residents. Trump remarked that US citizen “homegrown” prisoners would be next.

      Despite various judicial rulings, including a unanimous SCOTUS ruling that the administration should facilitate the return of Kilmar Abrego-Garcia, the White House has continued to organize more deportations and posted on X that Garcia will “never return.”

      A US-born man was also imprisoned yesterday in Florida due to an ICE hold, even though he presented an authentic US birth certificate. He has since been released.

      If the Executive branch does not accept the rulings of the judicial branch, rule of law ceases to exist in the US, paving the way for any and all “undesirables” to be sent to illegal detainment camps.
    3. RFK spouts misinformation and hatred about autistic people. Autistic and disabled organizers, alongside parents and teachers of autistic children were alarmed at RFK Jr’s hateful comments on autism and his department’s plan to find the “environmental causes” of autism by September. His quote: “Autism destroys families, and more importantly, it destroys our greatest resource, which is our children. These are children who should not be suffering like this, These are kids who will never pay taxes, they’ll never hold a job, they’ll never play baseball, they’ll never write a poem, they’ll never go out on a date. Many of them will never use a toilet unassisted…. We have to recognize we are doing this to our children, and we need to put an end to it.”
    4. (RFK Cont’d) Current studies show that nearly 80% of autism can be attributed to genetic factors. Recent increases in diagnosis and visibility are due to the reclassification of autism as a spectrum disorder, better screening, diagnostic, and support tools, and in-community living over institutionalization.

      RFK’s remarks rang false for many autistic people and their families who live full and meaningful lives (including autistic adults who pay taxes).

      Even in the case of high support needs individuals, no human’s value should be calculated by their monetary input into society. This is a direct regurgitation of eugenic rhetoric used throughout history to forcibly sterilize and murder disabled people, notably the Germans’ labeling of “useless eaters” as “drain” on society in the lead-up to murdering 300,000+ disabled people.
    5. HHS fallout reveals loss of Advisory Committee on Heritable Diseases in Newborns and Children (ACHDNC). The latest HHS cuts include ACHDNC, which helped identify which genetic screenings should be available for newborns and children, and standardize the process across all states.

      Without federal guidance and funding, states may or may not provide screenings, meaning that there will be delays and missed opportunities for early intervention in children with those conditions. Many of the conditions are rare, so families might not even know what to look for or ask their doctors about.

      The move is at odds with RFK’s professed desire to ameliorate “children’s suffering” in his remarks on autism.
    6. More HHS fallout. In addition to departments and programs noted in previous weeks, others continue to be endangered by the vast staffing cuts enacted across the department.

      The FDA announced yesterday their plan to remove their food safety inspection programs due staffing constraints. The risk of foodborne illness hurts everyone, but can be deadly for children, the elderly, the chronically ill, immunocompromised, and pregnant people. Certain foodborne illness, like listeria, also cause stillbirth.

      Due to the $11 billion in CDC funding cuts, many long-COVID education and research projects at the state-level have been forced to make drastic cuts or close completely. Researchers believe approximately 6 in 100 people develop a post-covid medical condition.
    7. HHS issues “clarification” regarding gender dysphoria in Section 504’s Final Rule. RFK Jr. issued a clarification this week, noting that the mention of gender dysphoria in the preamble of Final Rule is not actually an enforceable part of Section 504, as opponents of the suit have pointed out since the initial filing of Texas v. Becerra.

      However, precedent has been established for gender dysphoria being a protected condition under the ADA via other recent court decisions like Williams v. Kincaid.

      It’s unclear what this statement regarding Final Rule will mean for Texas v. Becerra, which remains ongoing.
    8. Texas v. Becerra lawsuit continues. Attorneys General continue to use transphobic rhetoric to attack Final Rule and Section 504, despite recent statements from HHS.

      Participants continue to say they do not want to dismantle disabled people’s rights, but have not revoked the original filing, which explicitly asks for 504 to be declared unconstitutional (p 37-42).

      504 protects disabled people’s rights in all spaces that receive federal funding, but could have major implications in conjunction with rescinding of ADA guidance, and the uncertain future of DoEd. The next update is due in the coming days.
    9. Local: Utah’s SB199 violates the ADA, due process. Late last month the Governor of Utah signed SB199, setting up a separate guardianship process for adults with “severe” disabilities.

      Guardianship protocol already exists in UT, but the new set-up allows people to circumvent due process if a doctor declares a person’s disability “severe.”

      Some disabled people benefit from guardianship arrangements, but all people have a right to due process, and the categorization of “severe” is vague.

      The ACLU is currently attempting to block the bill as a violation of one’s right to due process and the ADA.
    10. Do not comply in advance (good news). Due to pending legal action over McMahon’s DoEd issued directive to withhold funding from schools pending receipt of their anti-DEI loyalty pledge, a judge ordered that schools do not need to sign any certifications until at least April 24, after the legality of the pledge is assessed. Previously, the directive required school leadership to sign within 10 days.

      So far VT, MA, CT, NY DE, PA, MI, WI, IL, MN, CO, UT, OR, WA, CA, officials have declined to sign, while other states have declared their intent to sign or are still in review. See the full map here.

  • Week 8 Update

    Week 8 Update

    1. Hundreds of Illegal Layoffs at the Department of Education. DoED laid off over 1300 employees Tuesday night, nearly half the department. Secretary McMahon made a statement that layoffs would not affect special ed, nor any legally-mandated positions, but that was a lie.

      Layoffs were conducted without review via a generic, “Dear colleague” letter, including eliminating workers in mandated positions that are not allowed to be vacant by law. Many workers who were supposed to continue on until the end of the month or longer cannot consistently access their emails and computers due to DOGE control.

      The layoffs spanned a variety of departments, cutting large swaths of the Office of Civil Rights (OCR).The Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services (OSERS) was also impacted.

      The entire office providing funding for Gallaudet, NTID, the American Printing House for the Blind, Helen Keller National Center, and other special institutions has been laid off.

      There is also currently no director at the head of OSEP, the office overseeing IDEA. McMahon sparked anger in an interview after the layoffs, in which she revealed she did not know what “IDEA” stands for.
    2. Regional DoEd Offices Shuttered. In addition to the layoffs, seven regional Department of Education offices have also been closed down: Cleveland, Boston, New York, Dallas, San Francisco, Chicago, Philadelphia.

      Among many impacts, this will further delay already long wait times for students and families dealing with discrimination complaints.
    3. DOGE Continues to infiltrate Social Security Administration (SSA). The DOGE team continues to grow at SSA, in what journalists believe to be the largest presence at any agency. Musk and friends have alleged “mass fraud” at the agency, but have not produced any evidence of the claim.

      DOGE is currently considering cancelling benefits for nearly 200,000 people who receive social security benefits without a SSN; however the majority of those are disabled children whose benefits are redirected to a “designated payee” in their parent or guardian.
    4. DOGE takes aim at the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Under Musk, DOGE targeted HUD for layoffs of around half of the department, which oversees housing vouchers, rental assistance, public housing and a variety of anti-homelessness initiatives, including rebuild grants for communities after disaster.

      HUD also oversees fair housing laws and fields discrimination complaints.

      At least 50% of the US’s unhoused population is disabled.
    5. Senate Finance Committee holds hearing for Dr. Mehmet Oz. TV personality “Doctor Oz” was tapped to be Administrator of the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services, and began his hearing Friday.

      He is poised to oversee Medicaid, Medicare, and administrative duties related to the Affordable Care Act as Republicans vow to make deep cuts to the former two programs. Oz sidestepped questions about whether he would protect Medicaid from cuts during Friday’s hearing.
    6. Senate passes a Continuing Resolution for the GOP’s budget bill. Republicans, with the help of 10 Democrats, voted to pass a continuing resolution that avoids a government shutdown until September.

      A coalition of anti-Trump organizers, including the federal workers union, had rallied to encourage Democrats to vote NO, in an effort to bring Republicans to the negotiating table and include language to reign in DOGE’s unfettered slashing of federal programs and employment. Instead, a small group of Democrats helped push the bill through.

      Now that Democrats have ceded their leverage it will be difficult to stop further implementation of Project 2025 or DOGE cuts, beyond lawsuits after the fact.
    7. Texas vs. Beccera lawsuit continues. Attorneys General continue to use transphobic rhetoric to attack Final Rule and Section 504.

      Participants continue to say they do not want to dismantle disabled people’s rights, but have not revoked the original filing, which explicitly asks for 504 to be declared unconstitutional (p 37-42).

      504 protects disabled people’s rights in all spaces that receive federal funding, but could have major implications for those needing interpreters in hospitals in light of the new English EO.
      The next update is due in April.
    8. Good News… 21 Attorneys General have banded together to sue the administration regarding the illegal firings of Department of Education employees. This comes alongside previously established suits and union actions already in-play for other firings and freezings across the federal workforce.

      A judge also ordered Thursday that probationary employees across multiple agencies who were laid off should be reinstated.

    Action Items:
    Share this info. Disability is often lost in mainstream coverage.

    • Call your Representative and tell them to intervene on behalf of the Dept. of Education.
    • Call the Senate Finance Committee members and tell them to vote NO on Dr. Oz.
    • If your state is involved, contact your Attorney General and ask them to withdraw from Texas v. Beccera. Tell them you stand in solidarity with disabled people, and trans folks.
    • Consider how you can pivot to creative and local acts of resistance now that elected officials have ceded negotiating power. Here are some ideas.